Metaplanet’s decision to sell 10,000 bitcoin and buy 11,000 back to prove it could raise cash has now shown up in its accounts as a ¥19.17 billion realized loss, and the roughly $97 million tax asset the company said could offset it has not been booked. The Tokyo-listed bitcoin treasury company reported a nine-month net loss of ¥27.16 billion, about $170 million, on Friday and cut its full-year revenue forecast by more than half.
The round trip in numbers
Metaplanet first disclosed the trade on Oct. 5. A subsidiary sold 10,000 BTC during the third quarter at an average of ¥12,470,098 per coin, raising ¥124.7 billion, and held the money in cash, dollar stablecoins and other liquid assets. It then bought 11,000 BTC in separate transactions at an average of ¥13,626,928, spending ¥149.9 billion. Holdings rose by a net 1,000 coins to 44,000 BTC at Sept. 30.
The company said the point was to show bond investors and credit rating agencies that it can turn bitcoin into cash. The sale proceeds roughly matched its bonds, borrowings and preferred shares net of cash and stablecoins, which came to ¥127.1 billion at the end of September, according to its quarterly report. Metaplanet said in the report that a company with a policy of not selling bitcoin, or one that shows reluctance to do so, may not get full credit for those holdings as liquid assets.
The test was not cheap. The repurchase price was about 9.3% above the sale price. Buying back only the 10,000 coins it sold at that average would have cost about ¥136.3 billion, some ¥11.6 billion more than the sale raised, before trading costs. Because the coins were carried on the books above the price they fetched, the sale also produced the ¥19.17 billion realized loss, all of it booked in the third quarter, according to a separate notice on non-operating items.
The tax asset that has not appeared
When it announced the trade, Metaplanet said the sale created a capital loss for U.S. tax purposes and estimated that a deferred tax asset of about US$97 million “may be recognized” at its U.S. subsidiaries. If booked, it said in the Oct. 5 notice, that asset could offset all or part of the gap between the sale and repurchase prices. It flagged at the time that the figure was preliminary and that the auditor had not confirmed it.
The September balance sheet shows deferred tax assets of ¥1 million, and the company recorded no deferred tax benefit for the third quarter. In its earnings presentation, Metaplanet said it is “currently developing and implementing its tax planning” and will decide whether to recognize the asset, and how much, after discussions with parties including its auditor. Using that loss would also depend on its U.S. subsidiaries having capital gains to set it against.
What else drove the loss
The rest of the loss came from marking bitcoin to market. Metaplanet booked valuation losses of ¥116.4 billion in the first quarter and ¥67.9 billion in the second, then a ¥176.3 billion gain in the third, leaving a nine-month valuation loss of ¥8.04 billion. Interest expense rose to ¥3.17 billion. A year earlier, the company had a nine-month profit of ¥13.53 billion.
The operating business grew but slowed. Net sales rose 30.5% to ¥5.9 billion and operating profit rose 26.5% to ¥3.48 billion. Sales from the bitcoin income business, which mostly earns option premiums, fell from ¥2.98 billion in the first quarter to ¥1.76 billion in the second and ¥867 million in the third. Metaplanet now expects full-year sales of ¥6.5 billion and operating profit of ¥3 billion, down from initial targets of ¥16 billion and ¥11.4 billion.
The company gave two reasons. With its mNAV, which compares its enterprise value with the value of its bitcoin, below 1.0 for most of the year, it avoided issuing new shares, which left less capital to grow holdings and the options business. It also plans to put proceeds from its ¥52 billion October convertible bond mainly into share buybacks. Between Oct. 14 and Nov. 12 it repurchased 108.7 million shares for ¥28.27 billion.
Where the balance sheet stands
Metaplanet’s 44,000 BTC cost an average of ¥15,555,717 each, or ¥684.5 billion in total. With bitcoin at about ¥10.67 million on bitFlyer on Saturday, those coins were worth about ¥469.5 billion, roughly 31% below cost and about ¥109 billion less than their ¥578.6 billion carrying value at Sept. 30. If prices stayed near that level through Dec. 31, the fourth quarter would carry another large valuation loss.
Borrowings under its bitcoin-backed credit facility, about $650 million drawn of $800 million, equaled 17.7% of the value of its bitcoin at the end of September, above the roughly 10% guideline in its own capital policy. The company said it intends to use part of the money raised after the quarter to pay those loans down. It also faces index pressure: MSCI will drop Metaplanet and Strategy from its indexes after Nov. 30.
Metaplanet said the sale did not change its policy. Bitcoin “remains the Company’s primary financial reserve asset,” it said, and it still plans to keep accumulating over the medium to long term.
FAQ
Why did Metaplanet sell 10,000 BTC?
To show credit rating agencies and bond investors that it could convert bitcoin into cash roughly equal to its outstanding bonds, borrowings and preferred shares. It then bought 11,000 BTC back in separate trades.
How much did the sale cost Metaplanet?
It booked a ¥19.17 billion realized loss on the sale, and it paid about 9.3% more per coin when it bought back. A U.S. tax asset of roughly $97 million that could offset part of that has not yet been recognized.
How much bitcoin does Metaplanet hold?
44,000 BTC as of Sept. 30, at an average cost of ¥15,555,717 per coin.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.


















