A federal judge in Manhattan has acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of all charges over the $25 million Ethereum exploit that prosecutors called a “first of its kind” wire fraud case, a year after their trial ended in a hung jury. US District Judge Jessica Clarke ruled on Monday that the government never showed the brothers made a material misrepresentation, which the wire fraud statute requires, and directed the court clerk to close the case. There will be no retrial.
What the judge decided
The brothers were charged in May 2024 with wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. Their trial ran for nearly four weeks, and after three days of deliberations the jury could not reach a verdict. Clarke then took up the defense motion for a judgment of acquittal and granted it in a 46-page opinion and order filed on Monday.
She was careful to say what the ruling is not. “The question before the Court is not whether the Peraire-Buenos’ conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes,” she wrote. The only question was whether the trial evidence could support the wire fraud and related counts. Because it could not, the money laundering conspiracy count fell too: it depended on the proceeds of a wire fraud that, in the court’s view, was never proved.
How the $25 million was taken
The opinion lays out the April 2023 scheme, which the brothers called “Omakase,” in some detail. They registered 16 validators and tested their approach dozens of times. When one of their validators got the chance to propose a block, they put eight “lure” transactions into the public mempool, each built to tempt a specific sandwich-trading bot. The bots took the bait and bundled them.
The brothers then used a flaw in the relay software used with Flashbots’ MEV-Boost. Relays checked that a validator had signed a block header but did not check two fields, the parent and state roots. The Omakase validator set both to zero, signed the blinded header, and the Ultrasound Relay revealed the block’s contents. With the bots’ trades in view, the brothers built a second block that swapped the lure transactions for “dump” trades that sold the tokens the bots had just bought, sinking the price before the bots could sell. The first block was invalid and rejected. The second went onchain.
Three sandwich traders lost money, about $25 million in total, according to the opinion. The validator was slashed 1 ETH, a wallet holding $3 million of the proceeds was frozen, and within 24 hours Flashbots changed the relay code so that a header is checked for a valid block before the contents are revealed.
Why the fraud theory failed
Clarke said the government’s list of alleged lies came down to three things: the lure transactions, the “false signature” on the zeroed header, and the brothers’ failure to follow MEV-Boost’s specifications. None of them, she found, was a material misrepresentation.
Prosecutors had compared the lures to spoofing, where traders place orders they plan to cancel. The judge rejected that. The lure transactions were real and were later executed, landing in a different block about a minute after the attack. They were also “not placed on a regulated market with rules prohibiting this conduct,” she wrote. Ethereum, the opinion notes, is a permissionless network with no terms of use, where bots compete for value “without the safeguards that exist in regulated markets.”
On the signature, she wrote that “the Government failed to grapple with materiality,” pointing to the lack of evidence about what the relay would have done had it known the header was wrong. The evidence that the brothers hid their plans and their identities went to intent, a separate element, and could not fill the gap.
What it means for MEV disputes
The ruling is a single district court decision, so it does not bind other judges. It does set a high bar for using wire fraud law against onchain tactics that exploit code rather than deceive a person: prosecutors have to point to a specific, material falsehood. The opinion leaves open whether other, uncharged laws could apply.
For Ethereum, the case also shows how much block production has relied on outside software. The bug sat in relay code run by third parties, not in the protocol. The planned move to enshrined proposer-builder separation, a central piece of the Glamsterdam upgrade, is meant to bring that process into Ethereum itself. The Block and Bloomberg also reported the acquittal on Monday.
FAQ
Were the Peraire-Bueno brothers found not guilty by a jury?
No. The jury deadlocked and a mistrial was declared. Judge Jessica Clarke later entered a judgment of acquittal, finding the evidence could not support the wire fraud and money laundering conspiracy charges.
Why did the wire fraud charges fail?
The judge found prosecutors did not prove any material misrepresentation. The lure trades were genuine and executed, and the government did not show the false block signature mattered to the relay’s decision.
Was the MEV-Boost relay bug fixed?
Yes. According to the opinion, Flashbots changed the MEV-Boost relay code within 24 hours of the attack and worked with other relays to update theirs.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.


















