Cardano’s delegated representatives have rejected a request to spend 22 million ADA from the network treasury on physical copper, giving it just 0.51% support against the 67% it needed. The vote closed on Sunday, and the on-chain tally shows the two other treasury withdrawals still on the ballot, including a 9.6 million ADA policing project, are on course to fail when their own votes close on Friday.
How the copper vote ended
Toto Finance, a US company that issues commodity-backed tokens, filed the governance action on Oct. 15 under the title “Cardano Strategic Copper Reserve.” It expired without approval at the epoch boundary on Sunday night, when epoch 668 began.
According to the on-chain voting summary from the public Koios API, five DReps backed it with about 20.0 million ADA of delegated stake. A total of 126 DReps voted no with about 2.86 billion ADA, roughly 143 times the yes stake. Eight DReps, holding 816.5 million ADA, abstained. Another 131.3 million ADA sits with the automatic no-confidence option, and 943.1 million ADA of delegated stake never voted, which counts against a treasury withdrawal.
The Constitutional Committee, which separately checks whether spending requests comply with Cardano’s constitution, gave it no support. Three members voted no, two in October and one on Nov. 2. CoinDesk reported that the other four of the committee’s seven members did not vote.
What Toto wanted to do
The proposal asked for a one-time withdrawal to Toto Finance to buy COMEX Grade 1 copper cathodes held in a COMEX-approved US warehouse and tokenize the metal as CuTT, one token per pound. The plan was to hold the copper for 18 to 24 months, sell it, and return the net proceeds plus any unused budget to the treasury by month 36.
Only 14,724,409 ADA, or 66.93% of the request, was earmarked for copper. The rest was split between technology and project management (2.64 million ADA), external operations and assurance (about 3.53 million ADA), execution (about 442,000 ADA) and independent administration (660,000 ADA). The on-chain metadata filed with the request warned: “No original ADA principal, copper appreciation, token adoption or profit is guaranteed.”
At least one voter objected to exactly that combination. DRep John MacPherson, explaining his no vote, said: “I’m not against putting real-world assets on Cardano, and this proposal is more honest about its risks than most.” He went on to say the plan asked the treasury to carry both copper price risk and ADA price risk.
The ADA price did part of the damage
The request has been widely described as worth about $5 million, which was roughly true when it was filed. ADA traded near $0.23 on Binance in mid-October, putting 22 million tokens at about $5 million. On Monday morning ADA was around $0.154, so the same request was worth about $3.4 million. In other words, the treasury’s ADA has lost about a third of its dollar value over the month the vote ran.
The treasury held about 1.43 billion ADA at the start of the current epoch, according to Koios, so the copper request amounted to roughly 1.5% of it. CoinDesk reported that holders have capped withdrawals at 500 million ADA through about July 2027 and that 457.4 million ADA of that had been committed as of Oct. 16.
Two more requests are short of the votes
The copper plan was the largest of the three treasury withdrawals open for votes this month. The other two expire at the next epoch boundary, at 21:44 UTC on Friday, and neither looks able to pass.
PFMS, a 9.6 million ADA request from Trivolve Tech, would fund a police evidence management system anchored on Cardano, with an Indian state government named as its first deployment. It has the most support of the three: 43 DReps with 1.40 billion ADA voted yes, or 29.92% under the treasury formula, against 58 DReps with 1.64 billion ADA voting no. Three committee members voted yes. Even if every DRep that has not voted backed it, yes stake would reach about 62%, below the 67% bar. It can only pass if DReps who already voted no change their votes, which Cardano allows before expiry.
AURORA, a 940,000 ADA request for shared credit-market infrastructure for Cardano lending apps, has 4.10% support and three committee no votes.
What to watch
Toto had not said whether it will resubmit, according to CoinDesk. The next check is Friday’s expiry for PFMS and AURORA, which would leave this round of treasury votes with no approvals. Any proposer that returns will get less in dollar terms for the same ADA amount if the token stays near current levels. This year’s ADA slide was covered in our June report on Charles Hoskinson’s warning.
FAQ
Why did the Cardano copper proposal fail? It needed yes votes from 67% of active DRep stake and Constitutional Committee approval. It got 0.51% DRep support and no committee yes votes before it expired on Sunday.
How much was the request worth? 22 million ADA. That was about $5 million when it was filed in mid-October and about $3.4 million at Monday’s ADA price of roughly $0.154.
Can the other treasury requests still pass? On current votes, no. PFMS could reach only about 62% even if all remaining DReps voted yes. It would need some no voters to switch before Friday’s expiry.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

















